After leaving their Amish communities, the original Breaking Amish cast members have navigated modern society, pursued new passions, and overcome challenges. Kate Stoltz launched a sustainable clothing line, Jeremiah Raber sells Tupperware, Sabrina Burkholder focuses on her family, Abe works as a truck driver, and Rebecca is a stay-at-home mom. Despite facing personal struggles, including addiction and public scrutiny, the cast has rebuilt their lives, finding love and new beginnings. Sabrina found love with Jethro Nolt, Abe and Rebecca got married, and Kate focused on her fashion career. As they continue to adapt to the complexities of modern society, their stories offer a glimpse into the complexities of Anabaptist values in the modern world, and there's still more to uncover about their extraordinary journeys.
Key Takeaways
• The original Breaking Amish cast, including Kate, Jeremiah, Sabrina, Abe, and Rebecca, navigated modern society while holding onto their Anabaptist roots.
• Kate Stoltz launched a sustainable clothing line, Kate Stoltz NYC, and balanced her fashion career with family bonds.
• Sabrina Burkholder overcame addiction, found love with Jethro Nolt, and started a family, becoming a sober mother.
• Abe and Rebecca got married, had two daughters, and evolved their marriage into a beacon of strength.
• Jeremiah Raber sells Tupperware in Ohio and faced public scrutiny, including a restraining order.
Breaking Amish: The Original Cast
Breaking Amish premiered 10 years ago on TLC, introducing audiences to five Anabaptist individuals who left their Amish communities to explore the world beyond their rural roots in New York City.
The show's original cast members, including Kate, Jeremiah, Sabrina, Abe, and Rebecca, started on a journey of cultural adjustment, maneuvering the unfamiliar urban landscape. Family dynamics played a significant role in their adaptation, as they struggled to balance their desire for independence with their loyalty to their Amish upbringings.
As they adjusted to modern society, they faced challenges in acclimating to new customs, social norms, and technology. Their experiences provided a unique glimpse into the complexities of Anabaptist culture and the challenges of reconciling traditional values with modern life.
Life After Leaving the Community
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5daf6/5daf64223d00bbe56e88c1ec96e44279af076802" alt="rebuilding after leaving cult"
As the Breaking Amish cast members journeyed out of their traditional communities, they embarked on a path of self-discovery, maneuvering through the complexities of modern society while holding on to their Anabaptist roots.
They faced numerous challenges, from adapting to new technologies to finding their way through relationships outside their close-knit communities. Despite the difficulties, they found ways to reconnect with their roots, often turning to community support for comfort and guidance.
Pursuing New Passions and Careers
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c6504/c65043a857889d02bc25cf62d15649c313381d35" alt="exploring new interests and opportunities"
Following their departure from the Amish community, the cast members of Breaking Amish pursued various passions and careers, leveraging their unique experiences to forge new paths in the modern world. They capitalized on their unique backgrounds to forge successful careers, often combining their newfound freedoms with their traditional skills.
- Kate Stoltz launched a sustainable clothing line, Kate Stoltz NYC, after interning with prominent fashion designers like Jason Wu and Cynthia Rowley.
- Jeremiah Raber now sells Tupperware in Ohio, a far cry from his Amish roots.
- Sabrina Burkholder has overcome addiction and is now focused on her family and well-being.
- Abe and Rebecca are building a life together, with Abe working as a truck driver and Rebecca as a stay-at-home mom.
- The cast members have truly reinvented themselves, embracing their new lives and pursuing passions that bring them fulfillment.
Overcoming Struggles and Challenges
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ff94c/ff94c8e7bcd6a662e7391d0d372d71bd3cc3d6c0" alt="conquering adversity with resilience"
Amidst their journeys of self-discovery, the Breaking Amish cast members faced numerous struggles and challenges that tested their resolve and perseverance. As they navigated their new lives, they encountered personal growth opportunities, often amidst turmoil.
Kate Stoltz, for instance, balanced her fashion career with maintaining family bonds, ensuring her Amish roots remained strong. Sabrina Burkholder, on the other hand, overcame addiction and is now a proud, sober mother. Abe and Rebecca's marriage, though initially tumultuous, has become a beacon of strength. Jeremiah Raber, however, faced public scrutiny, including a restraining order.
Despite these challenges, the cast members have demonstrated remarkable resilience, showcasing their capacity for personal growth and the importance of nurturing family bonds.
Finding Love and New Beginnings
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/42531/42531b28f0845fbb932ba57b4f38361cdcc4d0a3" alt="embracing change and growth"
After departing from their Amish communities, the Breaking Amish cast members began a journey of self-discovery, which ultimately led them to find love and new beginnings in unexpected ways. As they navigated their new lives, they discovered new relationships, fresh starts, and love stories that unfolded into new chapters.
- Sabrina Burkholder found love with her boyfriend Jethro Nolt and started a family.
- Abe and Rebecca got married and have two daughters, creating a new life together.
- Kate Stoltz focused on her fashion career and remains close with her Amish family.
- Jeremiah Raber's marriage to Carmela ended, but he continues to sell Tupperware in Ohio.
- Despite struggles, the cast members have found ways to rebuild and start anew, proving that it's never too late to find love and new beginnings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the Breaking Amish Cast Members Stay in Touch After the Show?
After the show, the Breaking Amish cast members' ability to stay in touch was influenced by their individual cultural adjustments and lifestyle choices.
While some, like Kate Stoltz, remained close with their Amish families, others, like Jeremiah Raber, struggled to maintain relationships due to personal issues.
Sabrina Burkholder, who overcame addiction, and Abe and Rebecca, who started a family, also went their separate ways, making it challenging for the group to stay connected.
Are There Any Plans for a Breaking Amish Reunion Special?
Rumors of a Breaking Amish reunion special have been circulating, sparking excitement among fans. One example of a successful reunion special is the Jersey Shore: Family Vacation, which brought back original cast members for a new adventure.
While there's no official confirmation, TLC has explored 'catching up' specials in the past, suggesting a potential reunion could be in the works. However, at this point, it remains speculation, with no concrete plans announced.
How Do the Cast Members' Families Feel About Their New Lives?
The cast members' families have had varying reactions to their new lives. Kate Stoltz remains close to her Amish family, valuing her moments with them.
Sabrina Burkholder's family has been supportive of her sobriety journey.
Abe and Rebecca's families have adjusted to their cultural adjustments, embracing their new life outside the Amish community.
Jeremiah Raber's family dynamics have been affected by his personal struggles, including a restraining order filed by his ex-wife.
Did the Cast Members Face Any Backlash From the Amish Community?
A million eyes were on them, but what happened when the cameras stopped rolling?
When the Breaking Amish cast members left their communities, they faced a cultural backlash, with some experiencing community ostracism. Jeremiah Raber, for instance, was shunned by his family and friends. According to Sabrina Burkholder, 'it was like we were dead to them.'
The cast members' decisions to leave sparked outrage, with many Amish viewing their actions as a betrayal of their faith and traditions.
Are There Any Spin-Off Shows or Projects Featuring the Cast Members?
Beyond the original show, cast members have pursued new ventures and solo projects. Kate Stoltz launched her sustainable clothing line, Kate Stoltz NYC, after interning for prominent designers.
Jeremiah Raber sells Tupperware in Ohio. Sabrina Burkholder has focused on her sobriety and weight loss journey.
Abe and Rebecca have maintained a low public profile, prioritizing family life. None of the cast members have collaborated on a spin-off show or joint project, instead focusing on individual pursuits.
Conclusion
As the curtains closed on Breaking Amish, the original cast members set out on a journey of self-discovery, exchanging horse-drawn buggies for city streets. Like a tapestry woven with diverse threads, their lives have been a rich mosaic of triumphs and tribulations.
As they navigated the uncharted territories of the English world, they've found solace in new passions, confronted personal demons, and forged unexpected bonds. Today, they stand as examples of the power of resilience, their stories a beacon of hope for those seeking a new path.